Clemmons, Alexa W.; Donovan, Deborah A.; Theobald, Elli J.; Crowe, Alison J.

10.1187/cbe.21-02-0054

Y

1931-7913

Biology, Science Instruction, Educational Change, Curriculum Development, Undergraduate Students, Student Experience, Science Curriculum, Teacher Attitudes, Competency Based Education, Outcomes of Education, Student Attitudes

One critical step in the challenging process of curricular reform is determining how closely a curriculum aligns with national recommendations. Here, we examine the alignment of teaching, assessment, and student experience in undergraduate biology courses with the "Vision and Change" core competency recommendations. We applied the intended-enacted-experienced curriculum model to obtain a more complete, multiperspective view of the curriculum. First, we developed and piloted the BioSkills Curriculum Survey with more than 100 biology instructors across five institutions. Using multilevel logistic regression modeling of the survey data, we found that instructors were equally likely to report teaching all competencies; however, they reported assessing some competencies more than others. After adding course characteristics to our model, we found that the likelihood of teaching certain competencies depended on course type. Next, we analyzed class materials and student perceptions of instruction in 10 biology courses in one department. Within this smaller sample, we found that instructors messaged a narrower range of competency learning outcomes on their syllabi than they reported teaching on the survey. Finally, modeling revealed that inclusion of an outcome on assessments, but not syllabi, increased the likelihood that students and their instructor agreed whether it was taught.

As Provided

DUE1710772

Higher Education; Postsecondary Education

2022

EJ1336392